MADRIGAL by J. Robert Janes

MADRIGAL by J. Robert Janes (Gollancz, £16.99 pp276)

a review by L J Hurst


At the beginning of all his St-Cyr and Kohler mysteries J. Robert Janes puts a disclaimer which concludes "during the Occupation of France the everyday crimes of murder and arson continued to be committed, and I merely ask, by whom and how were they solved". In Mr Janes this solution comes from Jean-Louis St-Cyr of the Surete and Hermann Kohler of the Gestapo working as a team, but as other SHOTS reviews of his earlier titles in the series have said Janes' style is so peculiar that you have to take his word for it that a solution has been achieved.

MADRIGAL has St-Cyr and Kohler seconded to Avignon, where a young woman has been found dead in the Papal Palace (now the home of the Archbishop, the Pope having gone back to Rome six hundred years before). She is dressed in a medieval costume, her buttons embellished with secret signs, and her throat has been cut. The costume she made, the reason she was wearing it: to attend an audition for the local glee club. And the local glee club? Like most of the clergy it becomes clear, they are keen photographers and orgiasts, as well as hypocrites and perhaps blackmailers.

This is war-time, though, and the murder of Mireille de Sinety throws up far more. How can her possible boyfriends be chased when they are nowhere to be found as all are avoiding compulsory transfer to work in Germany? And with the cold winter of 1942/43 driving everyone onto the black market for essential food as well as the little extras a life needs, with whom else might Mireille have been forced to associate? Witnesses would be afraid enough to admit dealing with the ration-breakers, let alone with possible murderers so there is plenty in the contemporary events of the Occupation to make a detective's work ten-times harder.

Ultimately, St-Cyr traces things back to an older embargo. St-Cyr knows what psycho-tropics might do - Kohler is still damaged from his amphetamine-driven breakdown in an earlier book - and France had long before outlawed others. That, though, he discovers, has not destroyed the taste for absinthe. It is being smuggled in from Spain and Switzerland, and it is in the crazed rites of the absinthe drinkers that an older murder is revealed - an absinthe drinker who became a victim of her fellow imbibers.

MADRIGAL is ultimately a grotesque parody. However, given the way Janes writes this is not evident. It is something to be realised later when considering this dark period of human history. I have Janes' books from five publishers now - this will not be his breakthrough work, but those who already like him will not be disappointed.

Return to Home Page

This review appeared in SHOTS The Magazine for Crime and Mystery

© L J Hurst 2001